Last Modified 13 May 2016

Publications of Joanna J Bryson

Most of this page is a slightly retro and chatty list to help people find my papers & decide which they want to read.  But yes, I do know you want to cite papers too, so I provide complete references for all published papers (please never cite drafts!) in html and bibtex.   The bibtex list is most likely to be kept up to date properly since that's the one I use myself.

References in HTML
References in Bibtex

I also have shorter lists of selected publications by topic area, see Cultural Variation in Cooperation, Understanding Natural Intelligence, Designing Intelligent Systems, and Action Selection my primate page (three lists really: General and specialised task learning, Evolving social behaviour (including emotions), and Evolving human-like culture (including language)).  On my robot ethics page I also have a list of AI ethics papers, and papers on machine consciousness and synthetic emotions.

My university also maintains a page of my publications with Open Access versions. It is sometimes wildly inaccurate, but does contain green Open Access versions of papers I haven't bothered to list below, either because they aren't very academic, they have errors not in the final version, or I just haven't gotten around to it. If you want the final PDF of any publication and it's not linked below (sometimes subtly), email me.

My very early papers are in postscript, recent years are in pdf, a few are in both.  If you have trouble viewing any papers, try these helpful instructions, or email me.

this year

Me & Paul Rauwolf, Trust Communication, and Inequality.  To be presented at The 38th Annual Meeting of the Cognitive Science Society, 10-13 August in Philadelphia, PA.  Reviews Paul's awesome work on understanding why it's adaptive to both have blind faith in others in your community, yet refuse to cooperate with those making unfair but mutually-beneficial offers, and gives a taster of my big summer project with Nolan McCarty about understanding the interconnection between inequality, political polarisation, and public goods investment.  This paper just shows a bit of one ABM, which I'll publish here by August.

Andreas Theodorou, Rob Wortham and I each had draft papers at the AISB Workshop on Principles of Robotics,  on April 4th 2016, Sheffield UK, which marked the Fifth anniversary of the publication of the EPSRCs Principles of Robotics.  I'm waiting to link the more polished versions of Andreas' & Rob's papers we're submitting to journals, but the entire proceedings is available on that web page, or here's my entry: The meaning of the EPSRC principles of robotics.

Patiency Is Not a Virtue: AI and the Design of Ethical Systems.  Morality and AI are both artefacts of our culture, so of course we could construct them such that AI would be a moral patient, but who would that benefit?  Neither us nor the machines.  To appear in the proceedings of the AAAI Spring Symposium Ethical and Moral Considerations in Nonhuman Agents, and also to be presented at the AAAI Workshop AI, Ethics, and Society 13 February 2016.  Update of previous AISB paper from Gunkel's & my 2013 symposium.

Bidan Huang, Miao Li, Ravin Luis De Souza, me, and Aude Billard, A modular approach to learning manipulation strategies from human demonstration, Autonomous Robots 40(5):903-927.  Precise manipulation (e.g. opening bottle caps) on real robots using social learning via contact sensors.  Published online October 2015, in print June 2016.  Open access available from authors, or Bath one day I hope.

Draft: Rob Wortham and Joanna J. Bryson, Communication. A summary of everything biology and biological anthropology have to say on the subject, for the benefit of roboticists in particular. To appear in Living Machines: A Handbook of Research in Biomimetic and Biohybrid Systems, Prescott and Verschure, eds, Oxford University Press. Draft as of late November 2014, comments (and figure suggestions) welcome.

References in HTML
References in Bibtex


Artificial Intelligence and Pro-Social Behaviour from the October 2015 Springer volume, Collective Agency and Cooperation in Natural and Artificial Systems: Explanation, Implementation and Simulation derived from Catrin Misselhorn's 2013 meeting, Collective Agency and Cooperation in Natural and Artificial Systems.  This brings together all three threads of my research: action selection, natural cognition and collective behaviour, and the mischaracterisation of AI as an active threat.  In response to the apocalyptic futurism typified by Bostrom's Superintelligence, I frame AI as an ordinary part of human culture, which for 10,000 years has included physical artefacts that enhance our cognitive capacities, and is apocalyptic enough in its own right.  Open access: here's the post-review submitted version from September 2014, or email me for the corrected final.

Yifei Wang, Yinghong Lan, Daniel Weinreich, Nick Priest and I, Recombination Is Surprisingly Constructive for Artificial Gene Regulatory Networks in the Context of Selection for Developmental Stability, to appear in the proceedings of The 13th European Conference on Artificial Life, July 20-24 2015, York, UK. The title says it all, except I think that I think we may be onto something really significant for machine learning as well as theoretical biology here. Camera ready copy from May 2015.

Paul Rauwolf, Dominic Mitchell, and Joanna J. Bryson, Value homophily benefits cooperation but motivates employing incorrect social information, Journal of Theoretical Biology 367:246261. Preferring to cooperate with those with a similar cooperation style supports the evolution of cooperation. Reputations spread through gossip supports this strategy. But now that you are spreading two kinds of information (reputations of others, and your own style of cooperation) you can have a conundrum when these conflict. When there is such a conflict, signalling honestly about your cooperation strategy can be more beneficial to your community than telling the truth about someone else. Free open access draft is here. Software is coming soon. Draft is from October 2014.

Swen E. Gaudl, Joseph Carter Osborn, and I, Learning from Play: Facilitating Character Design Through Genetic Programming and Human Mimicry, from Progress in Artificial Intelligence: Proceedings of 17th Portuguese Conference on Artificial Intelligence, EPIA 2015, Coimbra, Portugal, September 8-11, 2015. Also solving AI through social learning, this time game character strategies derived from human game traces.  Open access camera ready version.

References in HTML
References in Bibtex


Daniel J. Taylor and Joanna J. Bryson, Replicators, lineages, and interactors, Behavioral and Brain Sciences, Volume 37, Issue 03, June 2014, pp 276-277, a commentary on Paul Smaldino's The cultural evolution of emergent group-level traitsOpen access version.

Joanna J. Bryson, James Mitchell, Simon T. Powers, and Karolina Sylwester, Understanding and Addressing Cultural Variation in Costly Antisocial Punishment.  which appears in Applied Evolutionary Anthropology: Darwinian Approaches to Contemporary World Issues, Gibson & Lawson (eds.), Springer.  This book follows from a workshop.  Here is a free version of the chapter, the revised draft from May 2013.  See further our Cultural Variation in Costly Punishment project page.  Note: Google Scholar managed to find a USAF white paper derived from our final report by the same title which has a lot of irrelevant detail and a couple theoretical errors we've since discovered.  The book chapter is 15 months more recent.

Yifei Wang, Stephen G. Matthews and Joanna J. Bryson, Evolving Evolvability in the Context of Environmental Change: A Gene Regulatory Network (GRN) Approach, Artificial Life 2014.  Interesting for both biology & machine learning, looks at the role of a potentially-hierarchical network representation in the genome for handling semi-predictable environmental change.  Final version is open access, because computer science has archival conferences.

We had three non-archival but interesting 4-page extended abstracts at Collective Intelligence (June 10-12 2014, MIT):

Swen Gaudl has been working on improving the emotional / durative action selection work I started with Emmanuel Tanguy (see below.)  Swen's published two papers on his new Extended Ramp Goal (ERGo) model:

Jekaterina Novikova, Leon Watts and I,  The role of emotions in inter-action selection. Interaction Studies, 15 (2), pp. 216-223.  A commentary on Social behaviours in dog-owner interactions can serve as a model for designing social robots in the same issue.  Submitted version is open access.

David Gunkel and Joanna J. Bryson (eds.) Introduction to the Special Issue on Machine Morality: The Machine as Moral Agent and Patient, Philosophy & Technology, 27(1):5--8, March 2014.

The Role of Stability in Cultural Evolution: Innovation and Conformity in Implicit Knowledge Discovery, book chapter in Perspectives on Culture and Agent-Based Simulations, Virginia and Frank Dignum, (eds), Springer, Berlin 2014.  Some simple simulations of culture and modularity showing interesting stability effects, inspired by a talk Dan Sperber gave in 2008. Open access draft from 2010. Open source netlogo model described in the paper on the AmonI Software Page.

Eugene Y. Bann and Joanna J. Bryson, The Conceptualisation of Emotion Qualia: Semantic Clustering of Emotional Tweets, Proceedings of the Thirteenth Neural Computation and Psychology Workshop (NCPW) which actually took place in July 2012, but finally got published in 2014 (Julien Mayor, ed.).  A chapter length description of our attempt to use social media as a source for a more accurate portrayal of the space of human emotions.  Derived from Eugene Bann's undergraduate dissertation.  A more recent paper by the same authors on a related topic came out in 2013

References in HTML
References in Bibtex


Karolina Sylwester, Benedikt Herrmann, and Joanna J. Bryson, Homo homini lupus? Explaining antisocial punishment. In Journal of Neuroscience, Psychology, and Economics, 6(3):167-188. A review article; see further our Cultural Variation in Costly Punishment project page. If you don't have access to APA, here is the revised final version submitted to the publisher (May 2013).

Bidan Huang, Joanna J. Bryson and Tetsunari Inamura, Learning Motion Primitives of Object Manipulation Using Mimesis Model, presented at Robotics and Biomimetics (IEEE-ROBIO) in December 2013. Describes a system of biases for allowing machine learning by observation of sequences of behaviour. Final version from November 2013.

Eugene Y. Bann and Joanna J. Bryson, Measuring Cultural Relativity of Emotional Valence and Arousal using Semantic Clustering and Twitter, Proceedings of Cognitive Science. Considers the most common "emotion" keywords on Twitter, and discovers that some concepts e.g. sleepiness and sadness are relatively culturally invariant, but others like "surprise" and "stressed" seem to be used quite differently in different global regions. Also, Europeans are the most positive and excited tweeters. Camera-ready from April 2013.

Swen Gaudl, Simon Davies and Joanna J. Bryson, Behaviour Oriented Design for Real-Time-Strategy Games: An Approach on Iterative Development for StarCraft AI, Foundations of Digital Games (FDG), Chania, Crete 14-17 May 2013.  Describes Simon Davies' undergraduate project on building strategic game AI, as extended using Swen Gaudl's new version of ABODE.

Jekaterina Novikova, Swen Gaudl, and I, Emotionally Driven Robot Control Architecture for Human-Robot Interaction, in the proceedings Towards Autonomous Robotic Systems (TAROS 2013), pp. 261-263.  Green open access version.

Bidan Huang, Sahar El-Khoury, Miao Li, Joanna J. Bryson and Aude Billard, Learning a Real Time Grasping Strategy, IEEE International Conference on Robotics and Automation (ICRA), Karlsruhe, Germany 6-10 May 2013.  Like the title says.  Work conducted at EPFL.

References in HTML
References in Bibtex


Harvey Whitehouse, Ken Kahn, Michael E. Hochberg, and Joanna J. Bryson, The role for simulations in theory construction for the social sciences: Case studies concerning Divergent Modes of Religiosity, Religion, Brain & Behaviour 2(3):182-224 (including commentaries and response.)  I'm particularly pleased about this paper because it shows clearly how models can advance even well-established social-scientific theories provided that we work directly with domain experts who really understand the theory and data.  There are some very pithy, quotable text about this in our response to commentaries, From the imaginary to the real: the back and forth between reality and simulationOpen access pre-proof version of the target article, and of the response to commentaries. Associated software is available from the AmonI software page, and also in the electronic appendix.  Oxford Anthropology have made a web page about our simulation of religion work.

Simon T. Powers, Daniel J. Taylor and Joanna J. Bryson, Punishment can promote defection in group-structured populationsThe Journal of Theoretical Biology, 311:107-116.  Penultimate version on arXiv.  This paper shows that punishment alone can't explain altruism, the papers that thought it could didn't take into account the well-documented behaviour of anti-social punishment.  Basically, some people punish those that contribute to the public good.  This is the first article of at least five we expect to publish explaining this phenomenon, and why it varies by culture.  See our Cultural Variation in Costly Punishment project page.

A Role for Consciousness in Action Selection in the International Journal of Machine Consciousness 4(2):471-482. The role is not so much for immediate selection, but for updating models for future selection. In case you don't have access, here's the submitted draft from July 2012.

The Machine Question: AI, Ethics and Moral Responsibility, David J. Gunkel, Joanna J. Bryson and Steve Torrance, eds..  A symposium proceedings published by The Society for the Study of Artificial Intelligence and Simulation of Behaviour.  Papers focus on the ethics of considering artificially intelligent artefacts as moral agents (actors responsible for their behaviour) and / or moral patients (individuals deserving of moral consideration / ethical treatment.)  Symposium ran 3-5 July, 2012, these papers were delivered a few weeks before that.

Patiency Is Not a Virtue: Suggestions for Co-Constructing an Ethical Framework Including Intelligent Artefacts.  Appeared in The Machine Question: AI, Ethics and Moral Responsibility, (Gunkel, Bryson and Torrance, eds, see above), pp. 73-75, but there's a nice new version now, see 2016.  Argues that both ethical systems and robots are artefacts of our society, so we have a good deal of control over whether we choose to make our agents moral subjects.  Doing so would be a displacement of responsibility that currently rests in us, and that displacement probably isn't justified or advisable.

me, Yasushi Ando & Hagen Lehmann, Agent-based models as scientific methodology: A case study analysing the DomWorld theory of primate social structure and female dominance, from Modelling Natural Action Selection (Seth, Prescott & Bryson eds.), CUP.  The discussion is updated from our 2007 PTRS-B article, though the models are not.  Penultimate draft from 2010, related (including improved) software is available here.

Structuring Intelligence: The Role of Hierarchy, Modularity and Learning in Generating Intelligent Behaviour, from McFarland, D., Stenning, K. and McGonigle-Chalmers, M. (eds.) The Complex Mind, on Palgrave MacMillan.  An invited chapter for a book written in honour of the late Brendan McGonigle. The chapter mostly takes a neuro and psychological approach, but last section is Eco Evo Devo, with some ideas I've been working on lately on the origins of cognition. This is the draft sent to the publisher in March 2010.

References in HTML
References in Bibtex


Modelling Natural Action Selection (Seth, Prescott & Bryson eds.) Book on Cambridge University Press. 20% discount for clicking this link. An expanded and updated version of our 2007 PTRS-B special issue which was a condensed version of our 2005 conference proceedings.  I think this is the last version of this work we'll see since we've now run through all the primary permutations for the order of the editors (see below).

Bidan Huang, Jason L. Leake and I, Humanoid Robots and Cognitive Systems Research: An Epistemological Case Study Based on the iCub. Presented at a poster at ICDL - EPIROB in Frankfurt in August. Final version from June 2011.

Just an Artifact: Why Machines are Perceived as Moral Agents, with Philip P. Kime, in the proceedings of The Twenty-Second International Joint Conference on Artificial Intelligence (IJCAI '11).  Final camera-ready version from April 2011.  This is a substantial updating & improvement of one of my (and Phil's) very first papers "Just Another Artifact" which we gave at a workshop in 1998.

Gideon M. Gluckmann & I, An Agent-Based Model of the Effects of a Primate Social Structure on the Speed of Natural Selection, in Evolutionary Computation and Multi-Agent Systems and Simulation (ECoMASS) at GECCO 2011 in Dublin. The paper is final from April 2011.

Jakub Gemrot, Cyril Brom, Joanna Bryson & Michal Bida, How to compare usability of techniques for the specification of virtual agents behavior? An experimental pilot study with human subjects, in the AAMAS 2011 Workshop on the uses of Agents for Education, Games and Simulations.  Draft from January 2011.

A Role for Consciousness in Action Selection, in Proceedings of the AISB 2011 Symposium Machine Consciousness.  Post-final version with typos corrected & a sensible citation style from April 2011. There's now an improved journal version, see 2012 above.

John Grey and I, Procedural Quests: A Focus for Agent Interaction in Role-Playing-Games, in Proceedings of the AISB 2011 Symposium AI & Games.  Final version from March 2011.

References in HTML
References in Bibtex


Philipp Rohlfshagen and Joanna J. Bryson, Flexible Latching: A Biologically-Inspired Mechanism for Improving the Management of Homeostatic Goals in Cognitive Computation 2(3):230-241.  Discusses a simple add-on mechanism for dynamic plans to allow sensible ordering of high-level drives, and explains why this problem is different from detailed action selection.  Lots of experiments, some maths and some discussion of the literature on cognitive control in natural and artificial intelligence.  Associated software comes with the standard python/jython distribution of BOD.

The Need for Cognitive Systems in Medical Care, in CyberTherapy and Rehabilitation Magazine 3(3):35-36, 2010. This is not the journal of the same name by the same group, but rather their trade publication. PDF is the draft copy sent them.

Crude, Cheesy, Second-Rate Consciousness from the proceedings of Brain Inspired Cognitive Systems (BICS) 2010.  This is an update of the AISB update of the Vienna Consciousness paper.  The next step should be a journal article. The title is a reference to a Dennett quote well worth knowing.  The paper claims we already have conscious robots and it's not that big of a deal.  It also puts forward some cool ideas about the functional role of the action-selection-related process that we experience as consciousness.

Cultural Ratcheting Results Primarily from Semantic Compression.  From The Proceedings of Evolution of Language 2010, Smith, Schouwstra, de Boer & Smith (eds.) pp. 50-57.  Discriminates the size of a culture (how much information can be transmitted from one generation to the next) from its extent (how much useful behaviour can be generated) and argues that the vast majority of cultural ratcheting is because the size of human culture finally got large enough that cultural evolution could start increasing its extent.

Why Robot Nannies Probably Won't Do Much Psychological Damage. A commentary on an article by Sharkey and Sharkey, The Crying Shame of Robot Childcare Companions, in Interaction Studies 11(2):196-200.

Robots Should Be Slaves.  In Close Engagements with Artificial Companions:  Key social, psychological, ethical and design issues, published by John Benjamins in March 2010, edited by Yorick Wilks.  The chapter says companion is the wrong metaphor for robots, which leads to the misallocation of both resources and responsibility to the detriment of our society.  Draft from 21 May 2009.

Simplifying the Design of Human-Like Behaviour:  Emotions as Durative Dynamic State for Action Selection, with Emmanuel A. R. Tanguy,  in The International Journal of Synthetic Emotions, 1(1):30-50 January 2010.  Penultimate draft, from May 2009. Related software and articles.

References in HTML
References in Bibtex


What was it with 2009? I wrote a lot more than four papers, but as of mid-January 2010, it looks like that's all that technically got published that year.

Building Persons is a Choice an invited commentary on an article by Anne Foerst called Robots and Theology, in Erwgen Wissen Ethik 20(2):195-197 (2009). It isn't that AI couldn't conceivably deserve ethical obligation, rather it would be unethical for us to allow it to. See further my page on ethics and AI.

Age-Related Inhibition and Learning Effects: Evidence from Transitive Performance, in Proceedings of the 31st Annual Meeting of the Cognitive Science Society (CogSci 2009) pp. 3040-3045.  The paper is a scientific consequence of the ideas put forward in "Crude, Cheesy, Second-Rate Consciousness" (see below), and the work I am doing on understanding the evolution of cognition.  It concerns the tradeoffs between individual and genetic learning, and whether these may be shifted on the basis of individual experience over an agent's life history.  Evidence is derived from models of macaque task learning.  Camera ready from April 2009.   Associated software comes with the standard lisp distribution of BOD.

Crude, Cheesy, Second-Rate Consciousness. Presented at the 2nd AISB Symposium on Computing and Philosophy in April.  Final draft from March 2009.  An earlier, shorter version discussing Dennett more directly is listed under 2008.  The scientific ideas (without mention of robots or consciousness) are supported in my CogSci09 paper, above.

Representations Underlying Social Learning and Cultural Evolution.  In Interaction Studies, 10(1):77-100.  The version linked from the title is the penultimate draft from December 2008.

References in HTML
References in Bibtex


Avri Bilovich and I, Detecting the Evolution of Semantics and Individual Beliefs Through Statistical Analysis of Language Use, Proceedings of the Fall AAAI Symposium on  Naturally-Inspired Artificial Intelligence, Washington DC, November 2008.  Associated software is on the AmonI software page.

The Role of Modularity in Stablizing Cultural Evolution: Conformity and Innovation in an Agent-Based Model, Proceedings of the Fall AAAI Symposium on Adaptive Agents in Cultural Contexts (AACC-08), Washington DC, November 2008.  Associated software is on the AmonI software page.

Philipp Rohlfshagen and I, Improved Animal-Like Maintenance of Homeostatic Goals via Flexible Latching, Proceedings of the AAAI Fall Symposium on Biologically Inspired Cognitive Architectures, Washington DC, November 2008.  Associated software comes with the standard python/jython distribution of BOD.  As of 2010 there is a much clearer journal version of this, see above.

Solicited Statement (DRAFT):  Crude, Chessy, Second-Rate Consciousness, presented at the Vienna Conference on Consciousness 2008, discussing Dan Dennett's contribution. An extended, peer-reviewed version of this paper appears above under 2009.

TALK: Intelligent Robotics in 30 Minutes, or equally AI in 30 slides. Customized for the BURST, who are mostly mechanical engineers with no knowledge of programming or AI.

Embodiment vs. Memetics, in Mind & Society 7(1):77-94 May.  Discusses the importance of the discovery that human-like semantics can be learned simply from observing large corpora, with ramifications for the evolution of language.  The final version is from November 2007, here is a penultimate draft from August for those who do not subscribe, although it has a couple gaffs in it.

The Impact of Durative State on Action Selection, appeared in Emotion, Personality, and Social Behavior at the AAAI 2008 Spring Symposia at Stanford in March.  This is a somewhat pedantic overview of the improvements we've made to BOD, POSH and of course AI action selection in general in the last three years, with an eye to pleasing the EPSRC since my grant with the same title just ran out.  Final version from January 2008. 

References in HTML
References in Bibtex


I'm suddenly getting a lot of speaking invitations:
Steven Butler and I, Effects of Mass Media and Opinion Exchange on Extremist Group Formation, in the proceedings of ESSA 2007.  Final version from 25 June 2007.  Associated software.

Representational Requirements for Evolving Cultural Evolution (archives), a target article in the web magazine interdisciplines' on-line conference, Adaptation and Representation.  This article describes some ideas I developed years ago while talking with Andy Whiten, and more recently talking with Mark Wood, about species-specific differences in capacity for social / imitation learning.  Online since 28 May, version is from a couple weeks before that.  A significantly longer version of this paper will appear in the journal Interaction Studies & is available under 2009 above.

DRAFT:  Hagen Lehman and I, Modelling Primate Social Order:  Ultimate and Proximate Explanations.  A peek at the new model we're building of the egalitarian / despotic variation in primate social order.  (Lest you think we only criticise other people's!)  DRAFT from April 2007.

Agent-based models as scientific methodology: A case study analysing primate social behaviour, with ANDO Yasushi and Hagen LEHMANN.  In Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society - B, Biology 362(1485):1685-1698.  This paper talks about how ABM fits in as a part of scientific methodology, and in particular analyzes as a case study the macaque social structure simulation in Hemelrijk's DomWorld.  The DomWorld link includes the associated software.  An earlier version of this paper with the predictions and not the full analysis appears under 2005 below (Lehmann et al).

Two special issues I edited last year have come out this year: 
Also, one came out that Ivana Cace really did all the work on:

There are associated introductory articles to the above special issues:
We have two papers in IJCAI 2007, presented in Hyderabad in January.  These are both final versions from October 2006:
Mark Wood and I, Skill Acquisition through Program-Level Imitation in a Real-Time Domain.  in IEEE Transactions on Systems Man and Cybernetics, 37(2):272-285.  This paper presents an imitation learning system called COIL (inspired by Deb Roy's CELL) capable of learning tasks in a dynamic real-time environment (Unreal Tournament). If you don't subscribe to IEEE, here is a draft from May 2006. An even older version is Bath Technical report CSBU-2005-16. Zip file of associated software.

Primate errors in transitive `inference': A two-tier learning model, with Jonathan C. S. Leong.  In Animal Cognition 10(1)1-15.   A model of transitive inference as the implicit learning of relationships between context-action pairs.  The first version of this work appeared in my dissertation in 2001.  Associated software.  I also wrote a bibtex style for this article / journal:  animalcog.bst

Ivana Cace and I, Agent Based Modelling of Communication Costs: Why Information Can Be Free, in Emergence of Communication and Language on Springer, edited by Caroline Lyon, Chrystopher L. Nehaniv and Angelo Cangelosi. Shows that the tendency to communicate information can be adaptive even though it has immediate costs to the communicators and there are free riders / information hoarders around the place.   A chapter-length extension of Cace & Bryson '05. Version from early March 2006.

References in HTML
References in Bibtex


Cyril Brom, Jakub Gemrot, Michal Bída, Ondrej Burkert, Sam J. Partington and I, POSH Tools for Game Agent Development by Students and Non-Programmers, in the proceedings of  CGAMES06.  Talks about the work we and Prague have done on extending our BOD UT framework, kind of a "best of" summary paper from the games perspective.  Final version from Nov 2006.

Cyril Brom and I,  Action Selection for Intelligent Systems, published as a European Network for the Advancement of Artificial Cognitive Systems white paper (August 2006).

Integrating Life-Like Action Selection into Cycle-Based Agent Simulation Environments, with Tristan J. Caulfield and Jan Drugowitsch.  Documents BOD/MASON.  In the proceedings of Agent 2005. It came out in 2006 because it took us while to get everything working & written about (thanks Jan!)  Version from July 2006.

Emmanuel A. R. TanguyPhil J. Willis, and I,  A Dynamic Emotion Representation Model Within a Facial Animation System.  In The International Journal of Humanoid Robotics, 3(3):293-300.  This paper presents a Dynamic Emotion Representation (DER) model, its implementation and an instance of a full humanoid emotional model built with it.  Penultimate draft version from May or June 2006.   A longer version (which I think is more interesting though some terminology is wrong) is also a Bath technical report CSBU-2005-14, from November 2005.

The Attentional Spotlight, from Minds and Machines 16(1):21-28.  Jon Dorbolo wanted someone to write about Dan Dennett and Cog, and apparently Dennett suggested me!  This isn't the usual kind of thing I write -- it's mostly anecdotes and amateur philosophy -- but people like it.  Talks about Cog's first years, modular AI, philosophy of science, being a grad student, and a bit about memetics.  Written in May 2005.

References in HTML
References in Bibtex


Hagen Lehmann and I, Tolerance and Sexual Attraction in Despotic Societies: A Replication and Analysis of Hemelrijk (2002).  In the proceedings of  Modeling Natural Action Selection. Final, 18 June 2005.  Extended in 2006 (printed in 2007), see above.

Edited Conference Proceedings:  Joanna J. Bryson, Tony J. Prescott and Anil K. Seth, Modelling Natural Action Selection: Proceedings of an International Workshop. Published by AISB, Sussex UK. For more information, see the MNAS Home Page. (July 2005)

Samuel J. Partington and I, The Behavior Oriented Design of an Unreal Tournament Character. A case study of using BOD, presents a very complicated POSH plan.  In the proceedings of Intelligent Virtual Agents 2005.  Final version is copyright Springer.  Updated 23 June 2005.

Paula M. Ellis and I, The Significance of Textures for Affective Interfaces. Shows that what picture is on a VR face has very significant impact on how the emotions are perceived.  In the proceedings of Intelligent Virtual Agents 2005. Final version is copyright Springer.  Updated 23 June 2005.

Learning Discretely: Behaviour and Organisation in Social Learning, with Mark Wood.  Talks about memetics, task learning, neuroscience and VR games --- what more could you ask? Proceedings of the Third International Symposium on Imitation in Animals and Artifacts.  Updated 16 January 2005.

Ivana Cace and I, Why Information Can Be Free. Shows that the tendency to communicate information can be adaptive even though it has immediate costs to the communicators and there are free riders / information hoarders around the place. Proceedings of the Second International Symposium on the Emergence and Evolution of Linguistic Communication (EELC'05).  Updated 16 January 2005.  Extended in 2006, see above.

References in HTML
References in Bibtex


Evidence of Modularity from Primate Errors during Task Learning, in the proceedings of the Ninth Neural Computation and Psychology Workshop (NCPW '04). Relates my transitive inference work to the localist vs. modularist neural representation debate that used to be a big deal at NCPW. Final: 29 Dec 2004.

Modularity and Specialized Learning: Reexamining Behavior-Based Artificial Intelligence, in the Proceedings of The Third International Conference on Development and Learning (ICDL'04): Developing Social Brains. A slightly longer & less informative version was presented at Adaptive Behavior in Anticipatory Learning Systems (ABiALS'02), but missed being in the proceedings due to an error on my part.  Final version:  20 September 2004.

Now for the tricky bit... (originally "Consciousness Is Easy, but Learning Is Hard"), invited article for The Philosopher's Magazine 28(4):70-72. Explains that everything with RAM has functional self awareness, video cameras have perfect memory, what makes us intelligent (and is computationally difficult) is generalising from experience, which involves forgetting / unconsciousness. PDF wanted...but you can get the first third of the article from the link.

The Role of Emotions in Modular Intelligent Control, with Emmanuel Tanguy, and Phil Willis.  Cover article (well, blurb!) for the 2004 Summer AISB Quarterly.  Final, 17 May 2004.

Bruce Edmonds and I, The Insufficiency of Formal Design Methods - the necessity of an experimental approach for the understanding and control of complex MAS.  In the proceedings of AAMAS 2004. Final, 30 April 2004.

Mark Wood, Jonathan Leong and I, ACT-R is almost a Model of Primate Task Learning:  Experiments in Modelling Transitive Inference, in the proceedings of  Cognitive Science 2004.  Final: May 2004.

Modular Representations of Cognitive Phenomena in AI, Psychology and Neuroscience (in HTML or PDF). In Visions of Mind, pp 66-89, Darryl Davis ed. Final, April 2004.

TALK/ABSTRACT: Language Needs A 2nd Order Representations + A Rich Memetic Substrate. Presented at Evolution of Language (Leipzig, April 2004). Updated 14 November 2003.

Action Selection and Individuation in Agent Based Modelling (in HTML or PDF). In The Proceedings of Agent 2003: Challenges of Social Simulation, David L. Sallach and Charles Macal eds. As final as you'll see here; updated 26 April 2004.

References in HTML
References in Bibtex


Emmanuel Tanguy, Phil Willis and I, A Layered Dynamic Emotion Representation for the Creation of Complex Facial Expressions. In the proceedings of Intelligent Virtual Agents.  Final version from July 2003.

The Behavior-Oriented Design of Modular Agent Intelligence (pdf). A practical guide to Behavior-Oriented Design (BOD). In the Proceedings of Agent Technology and Software Engineering (AgeS 02), edited by Jrg P. Mller. The final version is Springer. Updated 27 November 2002

Bryson, David Martin, Sheila I. McIlraith, Lynn Andrea Stein, Agent-Based Composite Services in DAML-S: The Behavior-Oriented Design of an Intelligent Semantic Web, in Web Intelligence, Springer 2003. Ning Zhong, Jiming Liu, and Yiyu Yao, eds. This is a longer, more detailed version of our IEEE Computer (2002) paper.  Here's a nice review of the book from IEEE Distributed Systems.

Where Should Complexity Go? Cooperation in Complex Agents with Minimal Communication (in pdf). Discusses when to use communication between agents in a multi-agent system vs. when to use behavior arbitration between modules in a modular single agent. Shows code from the primate colony simulation I'm working on with Jessica Flack. Final version is © Springer-Verlag. In the proceedings of the First GSFC/JPL Workshop on Radical Agent Concepts (WRAC). Updated 3 July 2002.

References in HTML
References in Bibtex


Language Isn't Quite That Special (HTML). Commentary on The cognitive functions of language by  Peter Carruthers, both in Behavioral & Brain Sciences (BBS). Updated 10 Dec, 2002. BBS called the issue this got printed in `Dec 2002' but it must have come out in 2003! Well, I try to keep this page in sync with the actual publication dates, maybe that's crazy...

Action Selection for an Artificial Life Model of Social Behavior in Non-Human Primates with Jessica Flack. Three-page abstract presented at  Self-Organization and Evolution of Social Behaviour. Talks about exciting new research I hope to be spending more time on one day. Updated 6 June, 2002 (older, 8 page version from 30 March, 2001).

David Martin, Sheila I. McIlraith, Lynn Andrea Stein and I wrote two versions of the same paper. The shorter and somewhat cleaner one we called Semantic Web Services as Behavior-Oriented Agents. IEEE Computer rewrote this a bit into something called Toward Behavioral Intelligence in the Semantic Web for a special issue. More technical details are in a Springer chapter which can be found above under 2003. Both the book and the IEEE Computer special issue are about Web Intelligence, and edited by Ning Zhong, Jiming Liu, and Yiyu Yao. The papers recommend that the semantic web be viewed as containing intelligence, not just information. They also provide recommendations for altering the DAML-S spec. to better support this. Read about it in Russian. Updated 25 July, 12 October & 7th of July 2002, respectively.

Representing Cognitive Phenomena in Biological Systems. An invited 3-page rant (plus 1 page of references) about modularity and `cognition'. May be coming out in a book edited by Alex Meystel. Updated 22 May 2002.

What Monkeys See and Don't Do: Agent Models of Safe Learning in Primates (in pdf), with Marc D. Hauser. A position paper, describes the importance of constraints in learning in artificial and natural agents. In the proceedings of the AAAI Spring Symposium on Safe Learning Agents. Final revision, 21 January 2002.

References in HTML
References in Bibtex


Intelligent Control Requires More Structure than the Theory of Event Coding Provides (HTML). Commentary on The Theory of Event Coding: A Framework for Perception and Action Planning by Bernhard Hommel, Jochen Müsseler, Gisa Aschersleben and Wolfgang Prinz, both appeared in Behavioral & Brain Sciences (BBS). Updated Nov 13, 2001.

Embodiment vs. Memetics: Does Language Need a Physical Plant? from the Proceedings of the Workshop on Developmental Embodied Cognition (DECO 01). I describe my model of how language connects to modular embodied intelligence in nature, and what this implies for AI. Just a position/review paper, no novel results, but good fun. Updated October, 2001 Er... my revisions were made far too late to make the proceedings, but the original isn't very clear!  There is now an even more revised version, see 2007.

PhD Dissertation: Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Department of Electrical Engineering and Computer Science

Intelligence by Design in pdf (postscript version). Warning: that version is 344 pages long, due to 140 pages of lisp code. I have broken the dissertation into its main text, code appendices and bibliography, (all in postscript), in the likely event you just want to read the text. You can also email me to ask for a copy of the printed Tech Report, which is paperback-like and doesn't have the code. The files above are from the TR, which is clearer than the submitted dissertation (pdf).

I also have slides and video online from the defense, which was 30 April 2001.

Modularity and Design in Reactive Intelligence in pdf (postscript), with Lynn Andrea Stein. From IJCAI 2001. A 6 page summary of my dissertation, including a description of BOD, differences between reactive agent architectures, and an overly brief example of using BOD. (Final from April 10, 2001.)

HOW-TO: How to Make a Monkey Do Something Smart (13 pages of pdf) A brief document about Behavior Oriented Design (BOD). (Slightly modified April 18, 2001.)

References in HTML
References in Bibtex


Dragons, Bats & Evil Knights: A Three-Layer Design Approach to Character Based Creative Play in pdf (draft version from 18 Dec. 2000). With Kris Thrisson. Final version appeared in Virtual Reality 5(2):57-71, a special issue on Intelligent Virtual Agents edited by Daniel Ballin. Article concerns the design of constructive narratives. Describes SoL (a hybrid architecture composed of Edmund and Ymir), a slightly modified form of BOD to support SoL, and our experiences developing AI for constructive narratives at LEGO.

Modularity and Specialized Learning: Mapping Between Agent Architectures and Brain Organization in pdf (postscript version), with Lynn Andrea Stein. From the proceedings of EmerNet2000 (Emerging computational neural network architectures based on neuroscience). Final version is Springer-Verlag. Discusses the relationship between agent architectures and neuroscience, and proposes a model for an agent capable of developing its own behavior / skill modules as well as learning new patterns of behavior. Target audience is neuroscientists and computer scientists interested in expanding neural networks to exploit modularity and specialized learning. Updated 3 December, 2000.

Modularity and Specialized Learning in the Organization of Behavior in pdf (or postscript). Written with Lynn Andrea Stein. Presented at NCPW6 in September, 2000, in the proceedings (the final version is Springer-Verlag). Summary: This chapter is similar to the EMERNET one just above, but shorter (10 vs 15 pages) and focuses on my BOD systems rather than agent architectures in general. Targeted for psychologists and cognitive scientists who use neural networks to model human behavior. Updated 30 October, 2000.

Hypothesis Testing for Complex Agents in pdf (or postscript), with Will Lowe and Lynn Andrea Stein. In the proceedings of the NIST Workshop on Performance Metrics for Intelligent Systems held in August, 2000 (original website). Talks in detail about experimental method and the development of complex (even socially competent) agents. Updated July 2000.

Architectures and Idioms: Making Progress in Agent Design in pdf (or postscript). Written with Lynn Andrea Stein. Presented at ATAL 2000, now a book chapter, the final version is Springer-Verlag. Summary: discusses the importance of methodology and the utility of alternative architectures - among other contributions, it distinguishes between these. Also gives a good one-page summary of what reactive planning really is. We suggest that the most useful thing to do with a new architecture is to identify its contributions and then express them in terms of one or more main-stream architectures. An extended example is made of an idiom we call a Basic Reactive Plan, taken from my architecture, Edmund, among other places. Updated 29 October, 2000.

Also at ATAL, Agent Development Tools with Keith Decker, Scott DeLoach, Michael Huhns and Michael Wooldridge. This is a synopsis of a panel discussion, with a fine two-page rant from me I still stand by. There's a free version on Scott DeLoach's publications page.

Hierarchy and Sequence vs. Full Parallelism in Reactive Action Selection Architectures (that's postscript), in The Sixth International Conference on the Simulation of Adaptive Behavior (SAB2000) (Note: there's a pdf version with an extra blank page.) Summary: demonstrates that hierarchy does not necessarily lead to a reduction of performance, even in highly dynamic environments. An illustration (with statistical evaluation) of the importance of clean design approaches to creating good AI systems. A shorter, less clear version of this paper appeared in Intelligent Virtual Agents 2, 1999. Final version; published in August 2000.

I presented two papers at two different symposia for AISB 2000. In Aaron Sloman's How to Design a Functioning Mind (DAM) I have Making Modularity Work: Combining Memory Systems and Intelligent Processes in a Dialog Agent (postscript version). First published description of BOD, uses dialog systems for the examples. (Final from March 2000.)

A Proposal for the Humanoid Agent-builders League (HAL) (or postscript) also appeared in the proceedings of John Barnden's symposium on Artificial Intelligence, Ethics and (Quasi-)Human Rights. See further my AI and Society web page. (Final from March 2000.)

Cross-Paradigm Analysis of Autonomous Agent Architecture in pdf (or compressed postscript) in the Journal of Experimental and Theoretical Artificial Intelligence (JETAI) 12(2). Summary: article about trends in agent architectures and what they imply about optimal strategies for designing intelligence.

MPhil Dissertation: University of Edinburgh, Faculty of Social Sciences (Department of Psychology)

The Study of Sequential and Hierarchical Organisation of Behaviour via Artificial Mechanisms of Action Selection. That is the 173-page 11-point 1.5-spaced PDF version, with a little source code my examiners asked for. There's also a 94-page 10-point single-spaced compressed postscript version with no source code. Complete source code is available at the bottom of this page. Summary: gives evidence for the need for structured control from three sources: the history of AI agent architectures, my experiments in two domains (robotics and artificial life), and a review of the neurological / behavioral literature. Also discusses the dialect differences between Psychology and AI, and AI as a research tool for Psychology. (Final corrections, January 2000).

References in HTML
References in Bibtex


Creativity by Design: A Character Based Approach to Creating Creative Play , in the AISB Symposium on AI and Creativity in Entertainment in April, 1999 Summary: another proto-BOD paper, talks about combining Edmund with another agent architecture, Ymir, in the context of virtual reality characters. More about SoL, Ymir and the project is in the "Dragons, Bats & Evil Knights" paper above; some of the technical details of implementing Edmund's POSH architecture in SoL are in "Architectures and Idioms" paper also above.

TALK: Intelligence by Design was presented to the Generator Studios artists group in Dundee Scotland, as part of the It's In Your Head art and neuroscience initiative in August, 1999.

Agent Architecture as Object Oriented Design, presented in Agent Theories, Architectures and Languages 1997, and published in Intelligent Agents IV by Springer in 1998. Summary: a proto-BOD paper, this describes developing behaviors and control scripts in a way similar to developing object hierarchies in OOD. Also mentions the way I have localized learning in the behavior libraries.

Just Another Artifact: Ethics and the Empirical Experience of AI. Coauthored with my friend Phil Kime, presented at the Fifteenth International Congress on Cybernetics, 1998, but only partially appearing in their proceedings.  We kept trying to make a journal version of this paper & finally in 2011 put a version into IJCAI which is I think a lot better. See also my AI and Society page.

Cognition without Representational Rediscription coauthored with Will Lowe. This is a commentary on Dana H. Ballard, Mary M. Hayhoe, Polly K. Pook, and Rajesh P. N. Rao, Deictic Codes for the Embodiment of Cognition; both articles appeared in Behavioral & Brain Sciences (BBS) in late 1997.

DRAFT: (from 1997): Specialized Learning and the Design of Intelligent Agents Old PhD proposal cum journal article under revision on the potential equivalence and trade-offs between control state and learning -- it's pretty rough in places but apparently also interesting (according to the reviewers.) This has been extended into two chapters of my PhD dissertation, the ones about learning. Maybe this year I'll resubmit it...

References in HTML
References in Bibtex


The Design of Learning for an Artifact from the AISB96 workshop on Learning in Robots and Animals. (There's also an older, longer version about Cog.) Learning in animals seems to be highly specialized and constrained as much as possible, primarily to things that cannot be learned in evolutionary time scales. As a developers of behavior-based AI, we largely take on the role of evolutionary learning ourselves. Our robots or avatars should only have the special-purpose sorts of learning built-in to their everyday actions.

DRAFT: (from 1996)  Modular Adaptivity and Behavior Based Control A short paper which discusses the role of episodic memory in navigation. I got some of this working on my robot, see my MPhil thesis, but some of it still needs to get worked out and written up...

DRAFT: (from 1995)  The Use of State in Intelligent Control . This short paper compares Shakey and Genghis, and demonstrates the necessity of using control state even in the simplest reactive system. I'm not sure anyone cares enough for me to ever get this one published! But I still think it could be useful for some people. (The original Genghis didn't actually back up and turn when it bumped into something with a feeler. It just lifted its leg higher.  Ooops.  Oh well, the same arguments still all apply.  The behavior I described was on the commercial version of Genghis available then from ISR (now iRobot.)

In Luc Steels (ed.) The Biology and Technology of Intelligent Autonomous Agents, (1994) The Reactive Accompanist: Adaptation and Behavior Decomposition in a Music System Describes my MSc project, is also the first place I suggest adaptive requirements can serve as a key to determining how to decompose intelligence into modularized behaviors (key point in BOD).

The Reactive Accompanist: Applying Subsumption Architecture to Software Design Edinburgh University Department of AI tech report 606 (1992) This paper is temporarily (January 2003) inaccessible due to the Edinburgh fire.   Since `temporary' has lasted for over two years, here's a draft version I still had the latex for.  Compares Subsumption Architecture with Object-Oriented Design in the context of my MSc.  Draft was last modified around November of 1992, it was placed here March 2005.

MSc Dissertation, University of Edinburgh, Faculty of Science (Department of Artificial Intelligence)

The Subsumption Strategy Development of a Music Modelling System. For more information, see my page on the Reactive Accompanist. (September 1992)

page author: Joanna Bryson

ml> /html> ="text/javascript"> _uacct = "UA-1903217-1"; urchinTracker(); ml> /html>